Tuesday, April 7, 2009

Loan Modification Success Rate

If you have some time to kill... feel free to read through the page-turner known as the:

"Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and Office of Thrift Supervision Mortgage Metrics Report, Disclosure of National Bank and Federal Thrift Mortgage Loan Data". (Full document here).

Assuming you won't actually read the whole document :-), allow us to highlight some of the findings for you:

  1. In 2008, only 41.85 percent of all modifications reduced monthly principal and interest payments for homeowners. For delinquent borrowers - - a loan modification resulted in an INCREASED or EQUAL payment amount 58.15% of the time!!
  2. If a loan modification resulted in NO CHANGE in principal and interest payments, that generally resulted in the homeowner re-defaulting 50.6% of the time after 6 months.
  3. If a loan modification resulted in an INCREASE in monthly principal and interest payments, that generally resulted in the homeowner re-defaulting 45.8% of the time after a period of six months. (Yes... it's interesting that an INCREASED payment has a lower re-default rate than a loan mod with no change in payment amount).
  4. HOWEVER, if a loan modification resulted in a reduced payment of 10% or more, the re-default rate shrank to just 22.7%. (77.3% success rate).
The national press jumped on the news a few weeks ago about the re-default rate of loan modifications (Here and Here, for example)... as 'proof' that foreclosure mitigation strategies don't work. What they DIDN'T mention is that NOT all loan modifications are equal - - some even INCREASED homeowners payments!

If you've thought about seeking a loan modification with your lender, or have already received an offer to modify the loan from them... you want to be EXTREMELY careful that the modification they're offering you is really in your LONG-TERM best interest. The Center's network of Foreclosure Counselors are ready, willing and able to take a look at the suggested modification, and help you decide if it will work for you.

ALSO... we couldn't post about loan modifications with warning Minnesota Home Owners AGAIN, to make sure that they do not PAY for any third-party loan modification service. Deal directly with your lender yourself, or with one of our free, non-profit Foreclosure Counselors. For additional warnings about for-profit loan modification companies (and scams)... visit here and here.


  1. Very factual data. Thanks for sharing.

  2. Good informative post. Thanks for sharing this data.

  3. Interesting!

    The loan modification process can be frustrating and confusing for many distressed homeowners. But you have to know what exactly is loan modification. A loan modification is a permanent change in one or more terms of a borrower's home loan.

  4. Understanding when to recognize a bad Mortgage loan may save you a lot of money in the long run.

  5. I totally agree with you. You won't have a hard time looking for a loan modification.


This is a moderated blog. That means all comments will be reviewed before posting. In addition, we expect that participants will treat each other, as well as the Center, our Counseling Network and other partners, with respect. We will not post comments that contain vulgar or abusive language; personal attacks of any kind; any offensive terms; spam; are clearly “off topic” or that promote services or products. Comments that make unsupported accusations will also not be posted.